Ever dreamed of snagging that game-winning fly ball? Our All-Star baseball glove is your ticket to the big leagues, whether you're a seasoned pro or just starting out. Crafted from premium leather, this glove offers superior comfort and a superb feel – perfect for fielding grounders and making those amazing catches. With its durable construction and snug fit, this All-Star will become your reliable partner on the diamond, helping you develop your skills and make every game a thrilling experience. Get yours and discover the difference a top-quality baseball mitt can make.
The selection process prioritizes superior product quality. Factors considered include material durability, optimal fit and comfort, effective impact protection, and design features enhancing performance. Extensive research and customer feedback ensure only top-performing items are recommended, leading to a curated list of excellent choices.
1. All-Star Pro 33.5" Catcher's Mitt
- Highly rated
- Glove size
- Durability
Dominate the diamond with the All-Star Pro Series 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt, a premium piece of equipment crafted for serious players. This adult catcher's mitt boasts a 100% full-grain US steerhide construction, ensuring exceptional durability and longevity. Its popular 33.5" pattern provides ample coverage, while the soft tan leather palm offers a quick break-in for immediate comfort. Reinforced with a firmer black leather back and edge, this mitt maintains its shape and provides superior protection game after game. The US grade tan rawhide lacing adds a touch of classic style and enduring strength. Experience the difference of professional-grade quality with this All-Star mitt.
The All-Star CM3100SBT catcher's mitt offers exceptional value and performance for serious players. Users consistently praise its soft, high-quality leather and surprisingly easy break-in period, making it a favorite among high school and 13U players. Many appreciate its durability, comparing it favorably to premium gloves like the Wilson A2000 or Rawlings HOH, but at a significantly lower price point. While some users noted a slightly smaller size than expected (compared to their previous gloves, perhaps due to differences in sizing across brands), the overall consensus highlights the CM3100SBT's excellent comfort and reliability. Adding the wrist guard (sold separately) enhances protection and further improves the user experience. This mitt is a fantastic choice for players seeking a durable, comfortable, and high-performing catcher's glove without breaking the bank.
- Brand: All-Star
- Color: Black and Cream
- Manufacturer: All-Star
- Material: Leather
- Size: 33.5
- Rate: 4.4 / 19
- High school varsity baseball
- Collegiate baseball
- Adult amateur baseball leagues
2. All-Star 9.5" Pro-Level Fielder's Training Glove
High-quality, affordable glove perfect for training and drills.
- Highly rated
- Glove quality
- Quality
- Fielding tool
- Value for money
Dominate the field with the All-Star The Pick 9.5 Inch FG100TM baseball fielder's glove. This premium training glove, crafted by a family-owned company with over 60 years of experience in providing top-quality baseball and softball equipment, boasts a fitted and streamlined design for superior comfort and protection. Its 9.5-inch size offers excellent control and feel, perfect for players of all skill levels, from little leaguers to professionals. The durable construction ensures lasting performance, allowing you to "move forward, rise above" your game. Experience the All-Star difference – superior quality and comfort in every catch.
This high-quality leather training glove is a fantastic addition to any baseball player's arsenal, from youth leagues to collegiate levels. Parents rave about its role in improving hand-eye coordination and building their children's fielding skills, perfect for perfecting techniques like Ron Washington drills. Users consistently praise the glove's exceptional value and durable construction. Its versatility shines through, proving equally effective for adults and young players alike, whether working on hand drills or taking ground balls. Many appreciate the superior feel of the ball in their hand, resulting from the glove's premium materials. Overall, this All-Star glove delivers excellent performance at a reasonable price, making it a reliable choice for serious training.
- Brand: All-Star
- Color: BK/TN
- Manufacturer: PROOK
- Material: Leather
- Size: 9.5
- Style: Right Hand Thrower
- Weight: 14.72 ounces
- Rate: 4.4 / 89
- 9.5 Inch Size
- Fitted and Streamlined Design
- Top Quality Materials
- Youth baseball leagues
- High school baseball teams
- College baseball programs
3. All-Star Pro Comp 33.5" Catcher's Mitt
High-quality, affordable glove; breaks in easily, but durability varies.
- Highly rated
- Quality
- Value for money
- Some controversy about
- Ease of break-in
Dominate the diamond with the All-Star Pro-Comp CM3200SBT 33.5" baseball catcher's mitt. Crafted from 100% full-grain cowhide for exceptional durability, this intermediate-level mitt boasts a professional-style black/tan design. Its oil-tanned leather and soft tan palm ensure a quick break-in and comfortable feel, while the Flex-Action heel and Pro Formed pocket provide superior flexibility and a secure ball capture. Featuring US grade tan rawhide lacing, this mitt offers the quality and performance of professional-grade gear at an intermediate price point, making it the perfect choice for aspiring catchers.
This catcher's mitt offers exceptional value for its price. Many users praise its comfortable fit and ease of break-in, with some achieving a perfect fit after minimal conditioning (e.g., using a light coat of glove conditioner). The high-quality leather is frequently noted, contributing to a professional look and feel. Parents particularly appreciate the glove's affordability, making it a great choice for young players. While some users experienced issues with the laces and leather tearing after limited use, the manufacturer's prompt replacement service mitigated this concern for some. Overall, this glove provides a superior playing experience for the price, making it an excellent option for those seeking a durable and comfortable catcher's mitt suitable for practice and games, even if some reinforcement might be desirable for intense use with fast pitches.
- Brand: All-Star
- Color: Black, Tan
- Manufacturer: All-Star Sporting Goods
- Material: Leather
- Size: 33.5"
- Rate: 4.3 / 62
- Oil-tanned genuine cowhide
- Flex-Action heel
- Pro-Formed pocket
- Intermediate level youth baseball
- High school baseball
- Collegiate baseball
4. All-Star Pro Elite Youth Catcher's Mitt (31.5")
Durable, high-quality glove, perfect for young athletes.
For young baseball catchers aiming to rise above, the All-Star Pro-Elite Travel Ball 31.5 Inch CM3000BTJR Youth Baseball Catchers Mitt provides superior protection and comfort. This top-quality mitt, from a family-owned company with over 60 years of experience in sporting goods, boasts a fitted and streamlined design for optimal performance. Its protective features ensure young athletes can confidently handle the demands of the game, while the comfortable feel allows for extended play. Built for little leaguers and aspiring professionals alike, the CM3000BTJR combines All-Star's legacy of quality with modern design to enhance every catch.
This All-Star baseball glove is a fantastic choice for young travel ball players. Its high-quality construction ensures durability for multiple seasons, fitting comfortably in smaller hands. While the break-in process requires some effort, the resulting performance is well worth it, creating a glove that holds a beautiful shape and provides excellent feel. Many users have praised the glove's superb quality, noting it as a worthy addition to their collection alongside other top brands like HOH. While some users experienced minor delays in shipping, the exceptional quality of the glove itself makes it a standout product. The glove's overall performance and long-lasting design, even with a slightly shallower pocket than some previous models, make it a valuable investment for any aspiring baseball player.
- Brand: All-Star
- Color: BK/TN
- Manufacturer: PROOK
- Material: Leather
- Size: 31.5 inch
- Style: Catcher
- Weight: 1.5 Pounds
- Rate: 4.4 / 27
- 31.5 Inch Size
- CM3000BTJR Model
- Protective and Comfortable Design
- Youth travel baseball games
- Competitive youth baseball leagues
- Baseball tournaments
5. Youth All-Star 31.5" Catcher's Mitt
High-quality youth catcher's mitt, breaks in quickly, excellent value.
Gear up for the big game with the All-Star Youth 31.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt, a premium piece of equipment designed for young athletes. Crafted from 100% full-grain cowhide, this mitt boasts a popular 31 1/2" pattern for optimal performance. The soft tan leather palm ensures a quick break-in period, while the firmer black leather back and edges maintain its shape throughout countless catches. High-quality US grade tan rawhide lacing adds to its durability and lasting appeal. This catcher's mitt provides the perfect combination of comfort, durability, and performance, making it a top choice for aspiring young ball players.
This All-Star youth catcher's mitt is a fantastic choice for young players! Parents consistently praise its excellent quality and superior feel compared to entry-level options. While some users noted a slightly longer break-in period than anticipated (easily remedied with regular catch and toss), the comfortable padding and impressive build quickly make it a favorite. Many reviewers highlighted the glove's great look and perfect fit for their 8-9 year olds, emphasizing the durable construction and overall value. One user even mentioned this is their second All-Star product, testament to the brand's reliability. This mitt is a solid investment for any young catcher aiming to improve their game, offering a significant upgrade from cheaper alternatives.
- Brand: All-Star
- Color: tan
- Manufacturer: All-Star
- Material: Leather
- Size: 31.5 inch
- Weight: 1.3 Pounds
- Rate: 4.3 / 37
- Youth baseball games
- Youth baseball practices
- Baseball training programs