Choosing the right baseball glove can be a challenge, especially on a budget. This review pits two popular, affordable options head-to-head: the Rawlings Select Pro Lite Bryce Harper and the Wilson A700, both 12-inch models. We put these gloves through a series of rigorous tests, including catching throws, fielding ground balls and pop flies, and simulating second base plays. Both gloves had seen some previous use (three and two months respectively), allowing for an evaluation of their break-in and overall feel. A well-worn practice ball added another layer of realism to our assessment. This comparison provides a detailed look at each glove's strengths and weaknesses to help you decide which best fits your needs and budget.This in-depth analysis goes beyond a simple spec comparison, examining how each glove performs under real-world conditions. We considered factors like pocket responsiveness, ease of fielding different ball types, and overall throwing accuracy. Whether you're an outfielder looking for a reliable glove or an infielder needing something versatile, this review will help you determine if the Rawlings Select Pro Lite or the Wilson A700 is the better fit for your game. The results might surprise you!
Pros And Cons
- Better for pop flies and outfield
- Bigger size catches better
- More poppy
- Harder to break in
- Smaller size may not be good for line drives
- Easier to break in
- Lighter weight
- Better for ground balls and first base
- Smaller size may not be good for line drives
Read more: Top 5 Wilson Baseball Gloves: Ultimate Buying Guide
Glove Introduction and Initial Impressions
We're comparing two budget-friendly baseball gloves: the Rawlings Select Pro Lite Bryce Harper 12-inch and the Wilson A700 12-inch. The Rawlings, a primarily leather glove with a palm pad, cost $50. The Wilson A700, also a 12-inch model, is designed for outfielders. Both gloves are not brand new, offering a chance to assess their wear and feel.
Initial impressions were that the Rawlings glove felt more broken in due to its three months of use, compared to the Wilson's two months. The ball used for testing is considerably worn. It will be interesting to see how the wear on the ball affects the performance of the gloves.
Catching Performance Test
The first test involved catching throws. The Wilson A700 initially performed better, demonstrating a more responsive pocket. However, the Rawlings glove improved as the test progressed, catching throws securely.
The difference in pocket feel was immediately noticeable. The Wilson glove's larger size seemingly improved its ability to catch the ball. Despite the initial differences, both gloves proved functional for catching.
Fielding Performance: Ground Balls and Pop Flies
The second test focused on fielding ground balls and pop flies. Each glove was used for five plays in each position. The Rawlings glove excelled at ground balls due to its broken-in feel, while the Wilson A700's larger size and design were better suited for pop flies.
The testers felt the Wilson glove demonstrated slightly better overall fielding, although both were effective. The test highlighted each glove's strengths, offering insight into their suitability for different fielding positions.
Throw Down Test and Final Verdict
The final test involved throw downs to simulate second base plays. The Wilson A700 initially proved better, making clean catches and throws, although one throw went over the fence. This led to the use of the worn practice ball.
Even with the less-than-ideal practice ball, the Wilson A700 continued to perform well. The Rawlings glove performed adequately, but the Wilson’s superior performance in the throw-down test secured its victory.
Overall Conclusion and Recommendation
Overall, the Wilson A700 emerged as the winner due to its superior performance in the catching and throw down tests. While the Rawlings Select Pro Lite performed well in ground ball fielding and is easier to break-in, the Wilson's size advantage and overall responsiveness made it a better choice.
The Wilson A700's larger size makes it preferable for outfield positions. It's slightly more expensive, but the improved performance justifies the price difference. Both gloves are viable options for budget-conscious players, but the Wilson A700 proved to be the more versatile and effective glove.