This article dives into a head-to-head comparison of two powerhouse Louisville Slugger BBCOR bats: the newly released SELECT PWR and the iconic SELECT 716, a favorite since 2016. Both are two-piece hybrid designs, but significant advancements in materials and technology have inevitably led to performance differences. We'll explore these differences through rigorous testing, examining key aspects like exit velocity, sweet spot size, swing weight, and the distinct sounds each bat produces. The legendary status of the SELECT 716, often praised for its unique "voodoo" effect, will be weighed against the cutting-edge performance promised by the SELECT PWR.This detailed analysis will help you understand the nuances of each bat, enabling you to make an informed decision based on your individual playing style and priorities. We'll dissect the subtle differences in design and construction, analyzing how these translate into on-field performance metrics. Ultimately, we aim to clarify whether the SELECT PWR's modern technology surpasses the nostalgic appeal and proven performance of the SELECT 716, or if the older bat still holds its own against the newcomer. The choice, as always, comes down to personal preference, but this comparison will provide the data to guide your decision.
Pros And Cons
- Legendary status in the BBC world
- Satisfying sound, no ping
- Big sweet spot
- Easier to get through the zone
- Better feeling barrel
- Amazing performance, even on the hands
- Efficient swing weight
- Good power
- Big sweet spot
- Slight ping if hit towards the hands
- Performance difference compared to Select Power isn't significant
- One of the best bb cores of the year, especially for power hitters
- Great sweet spot
- Hits the ball a mile
- Better exit velos than the 2020 Metapower
- Good performance in the hands
- Got beat a lot more with this bat than the 716
- Getting two balls a lot easier with the 716
- Two-piece hybrids are not known for super good durability
- Lots of issues with connection pieces on two-piece hybrids
Read more: Top 5 Best BBCOR Baseball Bats in 2024
The Contenders: A Look at the Bats
This comparison pits two Louisville Slugger powerhouses against each other: the newer SELECT PWR and the legendary SELECT 716 from 2016. Both are two-piece hybrid designs, but advancements in technology and materials are expected to yield differences in performance.
The SELECT PWR represents the latest in Louisville Slugger's technology, promising enhanced power and a larger sweet spot. The SELECT 716, despite its age, maintains a strong reputation among players, often described as possessing a unique 'voodoo' effect due to its enduring popularity and distinct sound.
Visually, both bats share a similar aesthetic but subtle design differences reveal their generational gap. The key is in how those differences translate to on-field performance.
Performance Comparison: On the Field Results
The testing involved hitting various pitches with both bats. The SELECT 716, despite its age, consistently delivered a satisfying crack and impressive distance, though some minor pings were observed outside the sweet spot.
The SELECT PWR, while not as sonically striking as the 716, showcased superior exit velocities and a more forgiving sweet spot, allowing for consistently powerful hits. The increased power and larger sweet spot were noticeable.
The differences in sound were significant. The 716's sound was more unique and satisfying, while the Select PWR offered more of a consistent, powerful thud.
Swing Weight and Feel: Subjective Analysis
The reviewer noted a slightly lighter swing weight with the 716, and found it slightly easier to get through the zone. However, the difference was subtle, barely noticeable to an untrained eye.
The SELECT PWR felt like it had a slightly heavier swing weight, with a bit more end load. This is a trade-off many players consider—more power but potentially less maneuverability. The larger sweet spot on the PWR also contributed to a difference in the feel of the bat.
The swing weight and feel preferences can change depending on individual batting styles and preferences. Both bats possess distinct qualities that could cater to different players.
Conclusion: Which Bat Reigns Supreme?
While the SELECT 716 boasts a legendary status and a unique sound, the SELECT PWR emerges as the superior performer, offering better exit velocities and a more forgiving sweet spot.
The age of the SELECT 716 is a factor. Its enduring popularity stems from nostalgia and a unique sound, not necessarily superior performance relative to modern bats. The newer SELECT PWR demonstrates advancements in bat technology.
Ultimately, the best bat depends on individual preferences and priorities. The 716 appeals to those who prioritize a distinctive sound and lighter feel; the SELECT PWR is the better option for those focused on raw power and a large sweet spot. Consider buying new with a warranty; used bats are notoriously unreliable.