The Louisville Slugger Seto Katsu first base mitt: a rare find from a discontinued line, this glove promises high-end performance but raises questions about its long-term durability. This review examines a glove lauded for its exceptional softness and immediate game-readiness, qualities reminiscent of a well-broken-in A2000. Made with thin Japanese leather, it offers a unique playing experience right out of the box, significantly different from the thicker, more durable leather found in other high-end models. But this remarkable suppleness comes at a potential cost.This review delves into the pros and cons of this unique mitt, weighing its exceptional playability against concerns about its longevity. We'll explore whether the Seto Katsu's remarkable softness and immediate usability justify its price point, ultimately determining if it lives up to the hype or represents a worthwhile investment for the discerning first baseman. The discussion will cover the glove's feel, performance, and the critical question of its long-term durability given its unusually thin leather.
Pros And Cons
- Made with very thin, soft leather
- Pretty much broken in upon arrival
- Game ready
- Thin leather might rip easily
- Quality leather not as high as older Louisville Slugger models (TPX)
- High retail price (250$) not recommended
Read more: Top 5 Wilson Baseball Gloves: Ultimate Buying Guide
Unboxing and First Impressions
I recently acquired a Louisville Slugger Seto Katsu first base mitt, supposedly a high-end model. Given that Louisville Slugger has been bought out by Wilson and discontinued the L Will Slugger line, this mitt represents a rare find from the Sato or Katsu models. The leather is exceptionally thin, immediately noticeable upon handling.
The glove felt remarkably broken in right out of the box, similar in feel to an A2000. This surprised me, as a brand new glove typically requires a significant break-in period. It was ready to use almost immediately.
Leather Quality and Feel
The incredibly soft and supple leather is a standout feature. The glove is described as very thin, like an A2000. This immediate softness is both a benefit and a potential concern, leading to questions about its long-term durability.
While the softness is impressive, it's notably different from the higher quality leather of other models like the TPX. Though made with Japanese leather, it feels comparatively less durable than some older Louisville Slugger models. The thin leather makes it extremely game-ready out of the box.
Performance and Durability Concerns
The glove's thin leather, while contributing to its immediate playability, also raises concerns about its long-term durability and ability to retain its shape. The reviewer wonders if the glove will hold up over extended use, given its already broken-in feel.
Despite the thin leather, the glove performs well. It's described as game-ready from the moment you take it out of the box. The concern, however, lies with the leather's potential for wearing down more quickly.
Value and Final Verdict
At a price point of $100-$125, this glove provides good value, particularly given its ready-to-use condition. However, prices closer to retail ($250) would be considered excessive.
Overall, the Seto Katsu is a decent glove. Its exceptional softness and immediate game-readiness are attractive features. The concern regarding the long-term durability due to thin leather remains. Whether this is a worthwhile purchase depends on the price and the buyer's tolerance for potentially thinner leather.
